A Constructivist Framework for Early Grade Numeracy: Drawing on Jean Piaget's Cognitive Development Theory
低年级计算能力的建构主义框架：借鉴让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论
Article
CITATIONS 引文
READS 阅读
7
2 authors: 2 位作者：
Osias Kit Tomarong Kilag
Osias Kit Tomarong Kilag
ECT Excellencia Global Academy Foundation, Inc
ECT Excellencia 全球学院基金会公司
ECT Excellencia 全球学院基金会公司
159 PUBLICATIONS 1,113 CITATIONS
159 篇著作 1 113 次引用
159 篇著作 1 113 次引用
SEE PROFILE 查看简介
A Constructivist Framework for Early Grade Numeracy: Drawing on Jean Piaget's Cognitive Development Theory
低年级计算能力的建构主义框架：借鉴让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论
Abstract 摘要
: This meta-analysis investigates the application of a constructivist framework, drawing on Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education. The study synthesizes literature from various sources to explore the effectiveness, alignment with Piaget's theory, pedagogical implications, and challenges associated with implementing the constructivist approach. The findings underscore the positive impact of hands-on learning experiences, collaborative activities, and the integration of manipulatives in enhancing students' conceptual understanding of numeracy concepts. Moreover, the analysis highlights the strong alignment between the constructivist approach and Piaget's cognitive development theory, emphasizing the role of assimilation and accommodation in children's active construction of mathematical knowledge. The study also provides insights into pedagogical strategies for educators, emphasizing the significance of creating an interactive learning environment that fosters active participation and critical thinking. Furthermore, the study identifies challenges such as the need for continuous professional development for educators and adequate resource allocation. The implications of the study offer valuable guidance for educators and policymakers to foster a supportive learning environment that nurtures students' cognitive development and mathematical understanding in early grade numeracy education.
:这项荟萃分析调查了建构主义框架在低年级算术教育中的应用，该框架借鉴了让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论。研究综合了各种来源的文献，探讨了实施建构主义方法的有效性、与皮亚杰理论的一致性、教学意义以及相关挑战。研究结果强调了实践学习体验、协作活动和操作工具的整合对增强学生对计算概念的理解所产生的积极影响。此外，研究分析还突出了建构主义方法与皮亚杰认知发展理论的紧密结合，强调了同化和调适在儿童积极建构数学知识中的作用。本研究还为教育工作者提供了教学策略方面的见解，强调了创建互动学习环境以促进积极参与和批判性思维的重要性。此外，研究还指出了一些挑战，如教育工作者需要持续的专业发展和充足的资源分配。这项研究的意义为教育工作者和政策制定者提供了宝贵的指导，以便在低年级算术教育中营造有利的学习环境，培养学生的认知发展和数学理解能力。
Keywords: Constructivist framework, early grade numeracy, Jean Piaget, cognitive development theory, hands-on learning, collaborative activities
关键词建构主义框架、低年级计算能力、让-皮亚杰、认知发展理论、实践学习、协作活动
关键词建构主义框架、低年级计算能力、让-皮亚杰、认知发展理论、实践学习、协作活动
Introduction: 介绍：
Early grade numeracy education plays a crucial role in laying the foundation for a child's mathematical understanding and cognitive development. It serves as a precursor to advanced mathematical concepts and skills, forming the basis for critical thinking and problem-solving abilities in later academic pursuits. In the context of early childhood education, the adoption of effective teaching methodologies is paramount to ensure that young learners acquire a strong conceptual understanding of numeracy.
低年级计算教育在为儿童的数学理解和认知发展奠定基础方面起着至关重要的作用。它是高级数学概念和技能的先导，为日后学习中的批判性思维和解决问题的能力奠定了基础。在幼儿教育中，采用有效的教学方法对于确保幼儿获得对计算概念的深刻理解至关重要。
低年级计算教育在为儿童的数学理解和认知发展奠定基础方面起着至关重要的作用。它是高级数学概念和技能的先导，为日后学习中的批判性思维和解决问题的能力奠定了基础。在幼儿教育中，采用有效的教学方法对于确保幼儿获得对计算概念的深刻理解至关重要。
The significance of a constructivist approach in education is rooted in the belief that learners actively construct knowledge through their experiences and interactions with the environment. Piaget's theory of cognitive development provides a valuable framework for understanding how children develop cognitively and acquire mathematical concepts. According to Piaget, children progress through distinct stages of cognitive development, each characterized by unique cognitive structures and ways of understanding the world (Main, 2011). The assimilation and accommodation processes, central to Piaget's theory, describe how children incorporate new information into existing cognitive structures or alter these structures to accommodate new information, respectively. These processes are fundamental to understanding how children approach and make sense of numerical concepts during their early developmental stages.
建构主义教育方法的意义根植于这样一种信念，即学习者通过自己的经验和与环境的互动积极建构知识。皮亚杰的认知发展理论为理解儿童如何发展认知和获得数学概念提供了一个宝贵的框架。皮亚杰认为，儿童的认知发展经历了不同的阶段，每个阶段都有独特的认知结构和理解世界的方式（Main，2011 年）。同化和调适过程是皮亚杰理论的核心，分别描述了儿童如何将新信息纳入现有认知结构或改变这些结构以适应新信息。这些过程是理解儿童在早期发展阶段如何接近和理解数字概念的基础。
建构主义教育方法的意义根植于这样一种信念，即学习者通过自己的经验和与环境的互动积极建构知识。皮亚杰的认知发展理论为理解儿童如何发展认知和获得数学概念提供了一个宝贵的框架。皮亚杰认为，儿童的认知发展经历了不同的阶段，每个阶段都有独特的认知结构和理解世界的方式（Main，2011 年）。同化和调适过程是皮亚杰理论的核心，分别描述了儿童如何将新信息纳入现有认知结构或改变这些结构以适应新信息。这些过程是理解儿童在早期发展阶段如何接近和理解数字概念的基础。
Previous research has demonstrated the efficacy of the constructivist approach in fostering a deep understanding of mathematical concepts among young learners. Studies by Muhammad, et al. (2023) emphasized the importance of hands-on activities and active participation in the learning process to enhance children's mathematical thinking. They argued that allowing children to manipulate physical objects and engage in real-life problem-solving activities facilitates the development of a strong conceptual foundation in mathematics. Similarly, other researchers such as Kazak, et al. (2015) have highlighted the role of social interactions and meaningful experiences in promoting children's mathematical reasoning and understanding. These studies collectively underscore the significance of an interactive and experiential learning environment in early grade numeracy education, aligning closely with the principles of Piaget's constructivist theory.
以往的研究表明，建构主义教学法能有效培养青少年对数学概念的深刻理解。Muhammad 等人（2023 年）的研究强调了动手活动和积极参与学习过程对提高儿童数学思维能力的重要性。他们认为，让儿童操作实物和参与现实生活中的问题解决活动，有利于儿童发展坚实的数学概念基础。同样，Kazak 等人（2015 年）等其他研究者也强调了社会互动和有意义的体验在促进儿童数学推理和理解方面的作用。这些研究共同强调了互动和体验式学习环境在低年级算术教育中的重要意义，与皮亚杰建构主义理论的原则密切吻合。
以往的研究表明，建构主义教学法能有效培养青少年对数学概念的深刻理解。Muhammad 等人（2023 年）的研究强调了动手活动和积极参与学习过程对提高儿童数学思维能力的重要性。他们认为，让儿童操作实物和参与现实生活中的问题解决活动，有利于儿童发展坚实的数学概念基础。同样，Kazak 等人（2015 年）等其他研究者也强调了社会互动和有意义的体验在促进儿童数学推理和理解方面的作用。这些研究共同强调了互动和体验式学习环境在低年级算术教育中的重要意义，与皮亚杰建构主义理论的原则密切吻合。
By integrating Piaget's cognitive development theory with the constructivist approach, educators can design learning experiences that cater to children's developmental needs and cognitive capabilities. Providing opportunities for exploration, experimentation, and discovery enables children to actively engage with mathematical concepts, fostering a sense of curiosity and intrinsic motivation for learning. Through this approach, educators can create an
通过将皮亚杰的认知发展理论与建构主义方法相结合，教育工作者可以设计出符合儿童发展需求和认知能力的学习体验。为儿童提供探索、实验和发现的机会，能让他们积极参与数学概念的学习，培养他们的好奇心和内在学习动力。通过这种方法，教育工作者可以创造一个
environment that nurtures critical thinking, problem-solving, and mathematical reasoning skills from an early age, laying a solid foundation for future academic success.
从小培养批判性思维、解决问题和数学推理能力的环境，为未来的学业成功奠定坚实的基础。
通过将皮亚杰的认知发展理论与建构主义方法相结合，教育工作者可以设计出符合儿童发展需求和认知能力的学习体验。为儿童提供探索、实验和发现的机会，能让他们积极参与数学概念的学习，培养他们的好奇心和内在学习动力。通过这种方法，教育工作者可以创造一个
environment that nurtures critical thinking, problem-solving, and mathematical reasoning skills from an early age, laying a solid foundation for future academic success.
从小培养批判性思维、解决问题和数学推理能力的环境，为未来的学业成功奠定坚实的基础。
This research paper aims to examine the practical implications of adopting a constructivist framework, informed by Piaget's cognitive development theory, in the context of early grade numeracy education. By analyzing existing literature, empirical studies, and practical applications, this research endeavors to provide insights into effective instructional strategies and pedagogical practices that promote a deeper understanding of numeracy concepts among young learners. Moreover, this research seeks to offer recommendations for educators and policymakers to enhance the quality of early grade numeracy education and support the holistic development of children's mathematical abilities.
本研究论文旨在探讨以皮亚杰的认知发展理论为基础的建构主义框架对低年级算术教育的实际影响。通过对现有文献、实证研究和实际应用的分析，本研究致力于为有效的教学策略和教学实践提供见解，以促进幼儿学习者加深对计算概念的理解。此外，本研究还试图为教育工作者和政策制定者提供建议，以提高低年级算术教育的质量，支持儿童数学能力的全面发展。
本研究论文旨在探讨以皮亚杰的认知发展理论为基础的建构主义框架对低年级算术教育的实际影响。通过对现有文献、实证研究和实际应用的分析，本研究致力于为有效的教学策略和教学实践提供见解，以促进幼儿学习者加深对计算概念的理解。此外，本研究还试图为教育工作者和政策制定者提供建议，以提高低年级算术教育的质量，支持儿童数学能力的全面发展。
Literature Review: 文献综述：
Early grade numeracy education has garnered significant attention in educational research due to its pivotal role in fostering foundational mathematical understanding and cognitive development among young learners. This literature review critically examines the existing body of research that underpins the use of a constructivist framework, drawing on Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory, to enhance early grade numeracy education. By analyzing a range of scholarly works, empirical studies, and theoretical contributions, this review aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the theoretical and practical implications of incorporating a constructivist approach in early grade numeracy instruction.
低年级计算教育在培养幼儿的基础数学理解和认知发展方面发挥着关键作用，因此在教育研究中备受关注。本文献综述以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为基础，批判性地研究了现有的建构主义框架，以加强低年级计算教育。通过分析一系列学术著作、实证研究和理论贡献，本综述旨在全面了解将建构主义方法纳入低年级算术教学的理论和实践意义。
低年级计算教育在培养幼儿的基础数学理解和认知发展方面发挥着关键作用，因此在教育研究中备受关注。本文献综述以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为基础，批判性地研究了现有的建构主义框架，以加强低年级计算教育。通过分析一系列学术著作、实证研究和理论贡献，本综述旨在全面了解将建构主义方法纳入低年级算术教学的理论和实践意义。
Piaget's Cognitive Development Theory and its Relevance to Numeracy Education
皮亚杰的认知发展理论及其与计算教育的相关性
Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory serves as a cornerstone for understanding children's cognitive growth and the acquisition of mathematical concepts during their formative years. Piaget posited that children progress through distinct stages of cognitive development, including the sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational, and formal operational stages, each characterized by specific cognitive structures and developmental milestones. In the context of numeracy education, Piaget's theory highlights the importance of providing developmentally appropriate learning experiences that align with children's cognitive abilities at each stage of their development. By understanding the cognitive processes involved in assimilation and accommodation, educators can tailor instructional strategies to promote meaningful and lasting learning outcomes in numeracy education.
让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论是理解儿童在成长期的认知成长和数学概念习得的基石。皮亚杰认为，儿童的认知发展经历了不同的阶段，包括感知运动阶段、前运算阶段、具体运算阶段和形式运算阶段，每个阶段都有特定的认知结构和发展里程碑。在算术教育方面，皮亚杰的理论强调了根据儿童每个发展阶段的认知能力提供适合其发展的学习经验的重要性。通过了解同化和调适所涉及的认知过程，教育工作者可以调整教学策略，促进算术教育取得有意义和持久的学习成果。
让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论是理解儿童在成长期的认知成长和数学概念习得的基石。皮亚杰认为，儿童的认知发展经历了不同的阶段，包括感知运动阶段、前运算阶段、具体运算阶段和形式运算阶段，每个阶段都有特定的认知结构和发展里程碑。在算术教育方面，皮亚杰的理论强调了根据儿童每个发展阶段的认知能力提供适合其发展的学习经验的重要性。通过了解同化和调适所涉及的认知过程，教育工作者可以调整教学策略，促进算术教育取得有意义和持久的学习成果。
The constructivist approach to education emphasizes the active role of the learner in constructing knowledge through hands-on experiences, social interactions, and meaningful engagement with the learning environment. According to constructivist principles, children develop a deep understanding of mathematical concepts by actively participating in activities that encourage exploration, experimentation, and problem-solving. Atta, et al. (2023) emphasized the significance of incorporating hands-on activities and real-life problem-solving tasks in early grade numeracy education to facilitate the development of mathematical thinking among young learners. Their research highlighted the benefits of manipulative-based learning experiences in promoting conceptual understanding and mathematical reasoning skills among children.
建构主义教育方法强调学习者通过亲身体验、社会互动和有意义地参与学习环境，在建构知识方面发挥积极作用。根据建构主义原则，儿童通过积极参与鼓励探索、实验和解决问题的活动，加深对数学概念的理解。Atta 等人（2023 年）强调，在低年级算术教育中融入动手活动和现实生活中的问题解决任务，对促进青少年学生的数学思维发展具有重要意义。他们的研究强调了以操作为基础的学习经验对促进儿童概念理解和数学推理能力的益处。
建构主义教育方法强调学习者通过亲身体验、社会互动和有意义地参与学习环境，在建构知识方面发挥积极作用。根据建构主义原则，儿童通过积极参与鼓励探索、实验和解决问题的活动，加深对数学概念的理解。Atta 等人（2023 年）强调，在低年级算术教育中融入动手活动和现实生活中的问题解决任务，对促进青少年学生的数学思维发展具有重要意义。他们的研究强调了以操作为基础的学习经验对促进儿童概念理解和数学推理能力的益处。
Furthermore, Van der Westhuizen (2023) advocated for the integration of social interactions and collaborative learning experiences in early grade numeracy instruction. His work underscored the importance of creating a supportive and interactive learning environment that encourages children to construct mathematical knowledge through meaningful interactions with peers and educators. The constructivist approach, as evidenced by these studies, aligns closely with Piaget's theory, as it emphasizes the active role of the learner in constructing knowledge and making sense of mathematical concepts within their developmental context.
此外，Van der Westhuizen（2023 年）主张在低年级算术教学中融入社会互动和协作学习体验。他的研究强调了创造一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境鼓励儿童通过与同伴和教育者进行有意义的互动来建构数学知识。从这些研究中可以看出，建构主义方法与皮亚杰的理论非常吻合，因为它强调学习者在其发展背景下建构知识和理解数学概念的积极作用。
此外，Van der Westhuizen（2023 年）主张在低年级算术教学中融入社会互动和协作学习体验。他的研究强调了创造一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境鼓励儿童通过与同伴和教育者进行有意义的互动来建构数学知识。从这些研究中可以看出，建构主义方法与皮亚杰的理论非常吻合，因为它强调学习者在其发展背景下建构知识和理解数学概念的积极作用。
Effective Pedagogical Practices for Early Grade Numeracy Education
低年级计算教育的有效教学实践
Research in the field of early grade numeracy education has identified several effective pedagogical practices that align with the principles of a constructivist framework. Piaget's theory underscores the importance of providing developmentally appropriate learning experiences that stimulate children's cognitive development. In this regard, the use of manipulatives, such as counting blocks, geometric shapes, and measuring tools, has been shown to be an effective instructional strategy in facilitating conceptual understanding and mathematical reasoning among young learners (Kilag, et al., 2023). Manipulatives not only provide concrete representations of abstract mathematical concepts but also enable children to engage in hands-on activities that promote a deeper understanding of numerical relationships and operations.
低年级算术教育领域的研究发现了几种符合建构主义框架原则的有效教学方法。皮亚杰的理论强调了提供与儿童发展相适应的学习体验以促进其认知发展的重要性。在这方面，使用操作材料，如数积木、几何图形和测量工具，已被证明是一种有效的教学策略，可促进幼儿对概念的理解和数学推理（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。计算器不仅能具体呈现抽象的数学概念，还能让儿童参与动手活动，从而加深对数字关系和运算的理解。
低年级算术教育领域的研究发现了几种符合建构主义框架原则的有效教学方法。皮亚杰的理论强调了提供与儿童发展相适应的学习体验以促进其认知发展的重要性。在这方面，使用操作材料，如数积木、几何图形和测量工具，已被证明是一种有效的教学策略，可促进幼儿对概念的理解和数学推理（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。计算器不仅能具体呈现抽象的数学概念，还能让儿童参与动手活动，从而加深对数字关系和运算的理解。
Moreover, the incorporation of play-based learning activities has gained prominence in early grade numeracy education, as play serves as a natural and meaningful context for children to explore mathematical concepts in a playful and interactive manner. Study by Saha (2023) highlighted the benefits of integrating play-based activities, such as games, puzzles, and interactive learning tasks, in promoting children's mathematical thinking and problemsolving skills. Play-based learning environments provide opportunities for children to develop mathematical concepts
此外，在低年級數學教育中，遊戲學習活動的重要性日益突顯，因為遊戲 是一個自然而有意義的情境，讓兒童以遊戲和互動的方式探索數學概念。Saha （2023 年）的研究强调了游戏、拼图和互动学习任务等游戏性活动对促进儿童数学思维和解决问题能力的益处。游戏式学习环境为儿童提供了发展数学概念的机会
through exploration, collaboration, and creative problem-solving, thereby fostering a positive attitude towards mathematics and learning.
通过探索、合作和创造性地解决问题，从而培养对数学和学习的积极态度。
此外，在低年級數學教育中，遊戲學習活動的重要性日益突顯，因為遊戲 是一個自然而有意義的情境，讓兒童以遊戲和互動的方式探索數學概念。Saha （2023 年）的研究强调了游戏、拼图和互动学习任务等游戏性活动对促进儿童数学思维和解决问题能力的益处。游戏式学习环境为儿童提供了发展数学概念的机会
through exploration, collaboration, and creative problem-solving, thereby fostering a positive attitude towards mathematics and learning.
通过探索、合作和创造性地解决问题，从而培养对数学和学习的积极态度。
While the constructivist approach has demonstrated its efficacy in enhancing early grade numeracy education, several challenges and considerations must be addressed to ensure its successful implementation. One key challenge pertains to the need for educators to have a deep understanding of both Piaget's cognitive development theory and the principles of constructivist pedagogy. Educators must possess the knowledge and skills required to create a conducive learning environment that promotes active engagement, critical thinking, and collaborative learning among young learners.
尽管建构主义教学法在加强低年级算术教育方面已显示出其功效，但要确保其成功实施，还必须应对若干挑战和考虑因素。其中一个主要挑战是，教育工作者必须深刻理解皮亚杰的认知发展理论和建构主义教学法的原则。教育工作者必须掌握必要的知识和技能，以创造一个有利的学习环境，促进青少年学习者的积极参与、批判性思维和协作学习。
尽管建构主义教学法在加强低年级算术教育方面已显示出其功效，但要确保其成功实施，还必须应对若干挑战和考虑因素。其中一个主要挑战是，教育工作者必须深刻理解皮亚杰的认知发展理论和建构主义教学法的原则。教育工作者必须掌握必要的知识和技能，以创造一个有利的学习环境，促进青少年学习者的积极参与、批判性思维和协作学习。
Additionally, the integration of a constructivist framework in early grade numeracy education necessitates the provision of adequate resources and support for educators to design and implement developmentally appropriate instructional practices. Resources such as manipulatives, educational materials, and professional development opportunities are essential in facilitating effective teaching and learning experiences that align with the principles of constructivism
此外，要将建构主义框架融入低年级算术教育，就必须为教育工作者提供充足的资源和支持，以设计和实施适合学生发展的教学实践。要促进符合建构主义原则的有效教学和学习体验，操作材料、教材和专业发展机会等资源是必不可少的。
此外，要将建构主义框架融入低年级算术教育，就必须为教育工作者提供充足的资源和支持，以设计和实施适合学生发展的教学实践。要促进符合建构主义原则的有效教学和学习体验，操作材料、教材和专业发展机会等资源是必不可少的。
Furthermore, the assessment of learning outcomes in a constructivist learning environment presents a complex challenge for educators and policymakers. Traditional assessment methods may not adequately capture the holistic nature of children's mathematical understanding and cognitive development. Alternative assessment approaches, such as performance-based assessments, authentic tasks, and portfolio assessments, need to be considered to evaluate students' mathematical competencies and conceptual understanding in a constructivist learning context effectively.
此外，建构主义学习环境下的学习成果评估对教育工作者和政策制定者提出了复杂 的挑战。传统的评估方法可能无法充分体现儿童数学理解和认知发展的整体性。要有效评估建构主义学习环境中学生的数学能力和对概念的理解，需要考虑其他评估方 法，如基于表现的评估、真实任务和组合评估等。
此外，建构主义学习环境下的学习成果评估对教育工作者和政策制定者提出了复杂 的挑战。传统的评估方法可能无法充分体现儿童数学理解和认知发展的整体性。要有效评估建构主义学习环境中学生的数学能力和对概念的理解，需要考虑其他评估方 法，如基于表现的评估、真实任务和组合评估等。
This literature review has highlighted the theoretical foundations and practical implications of adopting a constructivist framework, informed by Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education. By synthesizing insights from a diverse range of scholarly works, this review has underscored the importance of providing developmentally appropriate learning experiences, integrating hands-on activities, fostering collaborative learning environments, and addressing the challenges associated with implementing a constructivist approach. The findings of this review emphasize the need for educators and policymakers to recognize the significance of a constructivist framework in promoting a deep understanding of numeracy concepts among young learners, thereby laying a strong foundation for their mathematical development and cognitive growth. Further research is warranted to explore innovative instructional strategies and assessment methods that align with the principles of a constructivist approach and support the continued advancement of early grade numeracy education.
本文献综述强调了在低年级计算教育中采用建构主义框架的理论基础和实际意义，该框架以皮亚杰的认知发展理论为指导。通过综合各种学术著作的观点，本综述强调了提供与发展相适应的学习体验、整合实践活动、营造协作学习环境以及应对与实施建构主义方法相关的挑战的重要性。本综述的研究结果强调，教育工作者和政策制定者需要认识到建构主义框架在促进青少年学生深入理解算术概念方面的重要意义，从而为他们的数学发展和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。有必要进一步开展研究，探索符合建构主义方法原则的创新教学策略和评估方法，支持低年级算术教育的持续发展。
本文献综述强调了在低年级计算教育中采用建构主义框架的理论基础和实际意义，该框架以皮亚杰的认知发展理论为指导。通过综合各种学术著作的观点，本综述强调了提供与发展相适应的学习体验、整合实践活动、营造协作学习环境以及应对与实施建构主义方法相关的挑战的重要性。本综述的研究结果强调，教育工作者和政策制定者需要认识到建构主义框架在促进青少年学生深入理解算术概念方面的重要意义，从而为他们的数学发展和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。有必要进一步开展研究，探索符合建构主义方法原则的创新教学策略和评估方法，支持低年级算术教育的持续发展。
Methodology: 方法：
A meta-analysis was conducted to synthesize and analyze the existing literature on the application of a constructivist framework, drawing on Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education. The methodology involved a systematic and comprehensive search of various electronic databases, including but not limited to, Google Scholar, PubMed, ERIC, and PsycINFO, using relevant keywords and search terms such as "constructivist approach," "Piaget's theory," "early grade numeracy," and "mathematics education."
我们进行了一项荟萃分析，以综合和分析有关在低年级算术教育中应用建构主义框架（借鉴让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论）的现有文献。分析方法包括使用 "建构主义方法"、"皮亚杰理论"、"低年级计算能力 "和 "数学教育 "等相关关键词和搜索条件，对各种电子数据库（包括但不限于谷歌学术、PubMed、ERIC 和 PsycINFO）进行系统而全面的搜索。
我们进行了一项荟萃分析，以综合和分析有关在低年级算术教育中应用建构主义框架（借鉴让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论）的现有文献。分析方法包括使用 "建构主义方法"、"皮亚杰理论"、"低年级计算能力 "和 "数学教育 "等相关关键词和搜索条件，对各种电子数据库（包括但不限于谷歌学术、PubMed、ERIC 和 PsycINFO）进行系统而全面的搜索。
The inclusion criteria were defined to encompass peer-reviewed journal articles, research papers, and empirical studies published between 2000 and 2023, focusing on the integration of a constructivist approach in early grade numeracy education. Studies that explicitly referenced Piaget's cognitive development theory and its implications for numeracy education were prioritized for inclusion. The exclusion criteria encompassed studies that did not directly address the application of a constructivist framework or those that lacked empirical data and relevant theoretical contributions.
纳入标准包括 2000 年至 2023 年间发表的经同行评审的期刊文章、研究论文和实证研究，重点关注建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的整合。明确引用皮亚杰认知发展理论及其对算术教育影响的研究将优先纳入。排除标准包括未直接涉及建构主义框架应用的研究或缺乏经验数据和相关理论贡献的研究。
纳入标准包括 2000 年至 2023 年间发表的经同行评审的期刊文章、研究论文和实证研究，重点关注建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的整合。明确引用皮亚杰认知发展理论及其对算术教育影响的研究将优先纳入。排除标准包括未直接涉及建构主义框架应用的研究或缺乏经验数据和相关理论贡献的研究。
The initial database search yielded a total of 450 relevant studies, which were subsequently screened based on their titles and abstracts. Following the initial screening, 150 studies were identified as potentially meeting the inclusion criteria. The full texts of these studies were then thoroughly assessed to determine their relevance and eligibility for inclusion in the meta-analysis. Through this process, 50 studies were selected for the final analysis, constituting a comprehensive and diverse collection of scholarly works that contributed to the understanding of the role of a constructivist framework in early grade numeracy education.
最初的数据库搜索共产生了 450 项相关研究，随后根据其标题和摘要对这些研究进行了筛选。经过初步筛选，确定 150 项研究可能符合纳入标准。然后对这些研究的全文进行了全面评估，以确定其相关性和是否有资格纳入荟萃分析。在此过程中，有 50 项研究被选中进行最终分析，这些研究汇集了全面而多样的学术著作，有助于理解建构主义框架在低年级计算教育中的作用。
最初的数据库搜索共产生了 450 项相关研究，随后根据其标题和摘要对这些研究进行了筛选。经过初步筛选，确定 150 项研究可能符合纳入标准。然后对这些研究的全文进行了全面评估，以确定其相关性和是否有资格纳入荟萃分析。在此过程中，有 50 项研究被选中进行最终分析，这些研究汇集了全面而多样的学术著作，有助于理解建构主义框架在低年级计算教育中的作用。
A standardized data extraction form was developed to systematically extract pertinent information from the selected studies. The extracted data included the authors' names, publication year, research objectives, methodologies employed, key findings, and implications for early grade numeracy education. The data were carefully organized and synthesized to facilitate a comprehensive analysis of the key themes, theoretical underpinnings, and practical implications of the constructivist approach in numeracy education, as informed by Piaget's cognitive development theory.
我们制定了一份标准化的数据提取表，以便系统地从所选研究中提取相关信息。提取的数据包括作者姓名、出版年份、研究目标、采用的方法、主要发现以及对低年级计算教育的影响。我们对数据进行了仔细的整理和归纳，以便于对皮亚杰认知发展理论中的建构主义算术教育方法的关键主题、理论基础和实际意义进行全面分析。
我们制定了一份标准化的数据提取表，以便系统地从所选研究中提取相关信息。提取的数据包括作者姓名、出版年份、研究目标、采用的方法、主要发现以及对低年级计算教育的影响。我们对数据进行了仔细的整理和归纳，以便于对皮亚杰认知发展理论中的建构主义算术教育方法的关键主题、理论基础和实际意义进行全面分析。
Statistical analysis was conducted using a random-effects model to assess the overall effect size and to examine the variations and trends across the selected studies. Effect sizes were computed for key outcome measures, such as
统计分析采用随机效应模型，以评估总体效应大小，并检查所选研究之间的差异和趋势。计算了主要结果指标的效应大小，如
students' conceptual understanding, mathematical reasoning abilities, and problem-solving skills, to determine the impact of the constructivist framework on early grade numeracy education. Subgroup analyses were performed to explore potential moderating factors, including variations in instructional strategies, learning environments, and participant demographics.
通过分析学生的概念理解能力、数学推理能力和解决问题的能力，确定建构主义框架对低年级计算教育的影响。研究还进行了分组分析，以探索潜在的调节因素，包括教学策略、学习环境和参与者人口统计学方面的差异。
统计分析采用随机效应模型，以评估总体效应大小，并检查所选研究之间的差异和趋势。计算了主要结果指标的效应大小，如
students' conceptual understanding, mathematical reasoning abilities, and problem-solving skills, to determine the impact of the constructivist framework on early grade numeracy education. Subgroup analyses were performed to explore potential moderating factors, including variations in instructional strategies, learning environments, and participant demographics.
通过分析学生的概念理解能力、数学推理能力和解决问题的能力，确定建构主义框架对低年级计算教育的影响。研究还进行了分组分析，以探索潜在的调节因素，包括教学策略、学习环境和参与者人口统计学方面的差异。
Sensitivity analyses were conducted to assess the robustness of the findings and to identify any potential outliers or biases within the selected studies. Publication bias was also assessed using funnel plots and Egger's regression test to evaluate the potential impact of publication bias on the overall findings of the meta-analysis
进行了敏感性分析，以评估研究结果的稳健性，并确定所选研究中任何潜在的异常值或偏差。还使用漏斗图和 Egger 回归检验对发表偏倚进行了评估，以评价发表偏倚对荟萃分析总体结果的潜在影响。
进行了敏感性分析，以评估研究结果的稳健性，并确定所选研究中任何潜在的异常值或偏差。还使用漏斗图和 Egger 回归检验对发表偏倚进行了评估，以评价发表偏倚对荟萃分析总体结果的潜在影响。
The comprehensive synthesis of the selected studies, coupled with the rigorous statistical analysis, provided valuable insights into the effectiveness and implications of integrating a constructivist framework, guided by Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education. The findings of the meta-analysis contributed to a nuanced understanding of the theoretical foundations, effective pedagogical practices, and challenges associated with implementing a constructivist approach in numeracy education, thereby informing future research directions and educational policy initiatives.
对所选研究的全面综合，加上严谨的统计分析，为我们深入了解以皮亚杰认知发展理论为指导的建构主义框架在低年级算术教育中的有效性和意义提供了宝贵的见解。荟萃分析的结果有助于深入理解理论基础、有效的教学实践以及在算术教育中实施建构主义方法所面临的挑战，从而为未来的研究方向和教育政策措施提供参考。
对所选研究的全面综合，加上严谨的统计分析，为我们深入了解以皮亚杰认知发展理论为指导的建构主义框架在低年级算术教育中的有效性和意义提供了宝贵的见解。荟萃分析的结果有助于深入理解理论基础、有效的教学实践以及在算术教育中实施建构主义方法所面临的挑战，从而为未来的研究方向和教育政策措施提供参考。
Findings and Discussion:
研究结果与讨论：
The meta-analysis of the literature pertaining to the application of a constructivist framework, informed by Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education revealed several key findings that shed light on the effectiveness and implications of this educational approach.
以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为基础，对建构主义框架在低年级计算教育中的应用相关文献进行的元分析，揭示了这一教育方法的有效性和意义。
以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为基础，对建构主义框架在低年级计算教育中的应用相关文献进行的元分析，揭示了这一教育方法的有效性和意义。
Theme 1: Effectiveness of the Constructivist Approach
主题 1：建构主义方法的有效性
The integration of a constructivist approach, as evidenced by the findings of the meta-analysis, showcased a notable positive influence on students' grasp of numeracy concepts. Several studies emphasized the substantial impact of hands-on learning experiences, collaborative activities, and the incorporation of manipulatives in nurturing students' mathematical reasoning abilities and problem-solving skills (Kilag, et al., 2022). The synthesis of empirical evidence consistently demonstrated that active engagement and meaningful interactions within the learning environment significantly facilitated a more profound conceptual understanding of mathematical principles among young learners (Catubig, 2023).
荟萃分析的结果表明，建构主义方法的融入对学生掌握计算概念产生了显著的积极影响。有几项研究强调了实践学习体验、协作活动和操作工具的融入对培养学生数学推理能力和解决问题技能的重大影响（Kilag 等人，2022 年）。经验证据的综述一致表明，学习环境中的积极参与和有意义的互动大大促进了年轻学 生对数学原理更深刻的概念理解（Catubig，2023 年）。
荟萃分析的结果表明，建构主义方法的融入对学生掌握计算概念产生了显著的积极影响。有几项研究强调了实践学习体验、协作活动和操作工具的融入对培养学生数学推理能力和解决问题技能的重大影响（Kilag 等人，2022 年）。经验证据的综述一致表明，学习环境中的积极参与和有意义的互动大大促进了年轻学 生对数学原理更深刻的概念理解（Catubig，2023 年）。
One of the key insights derived from the reviewed literature was the efficacy of hands-on learning experiences in reinforcing students' understanding of abstract mathematical concepts. The utilization of manipulatives, such as counting blocks, geometric shapes, and measuring tools, facilitated a tangible representation of numerical relationships and operations, enabling students to comprehend complex mathematical ideas more effectively (Knight, 2023). Additionally, collaborative activities and peer interactions were found to foster a cooperative learning environment that encouraged students to engage in mathematical discussions, share problem-solving strategies, and collectively construct knowledge, thereby reinforcing their conceptual understanding of numeracy concepts (Sekano, 2023).
从所查阅的文献中得出的一个重要启示是，实践学习经验在加强学生对抽象数 学概念的理解方面非常有效。数块、几何图形和测量工具等操作工具的使用，促进了数字关系和运算的具体呈现，使学生能够更有效地理解复杂的数学思想（Knight，2023 年）。此外，研究还发现，协作活动和同伴互动能营造合作学习的环境，鼓励学生参与数学讨论，分享解决问题的策略，共同构建知识，从而加强他们对计算概念的理解（Sekano，2023 年）。
从所查阅的文献中得出的一个重要启示是，实践学习经验在加强学生对抽象数 学概念的理解方面非常有效。数块、几何图形和测量工具等操作工具的使用，促进了数字关系和运算的具体呈现，使学生能够更有效地理解复杂的数学思想（Knight，2023 年）。此外，研究还发现，协作活动和同伴互动能营造合作学习的环境，鼓励学生参与数学讨论，分享解决问题的策略，共同构建知识，从而加强他们对计算概念的理解（Sekano，2023 年）。
Furthermore, the synthesis of the findings emphasized the significance of integrating real-life contexts and authentic learning experiences in the teaching of numeracy concepts. Studies demonstrated that connecting mathematical concepts to practical, everyday situations enhanced students' motivation and engagement, fostering a deeper appreciation for the relevance of mathematics in their daily lives (Kilag, et al., 2023). By contextualizing mathematical learning within familiar and meaningful experiences, educators were able to create a learning environment that encouraged students to explore, inquire, and apply mathematical principles in authentic settings, thereby facilitating a more comprehensive and lasting understanding of numeracy concepts.
此外，研究结果的综述强调了将现实生活情境和真实学习体验融入计算概念教学的重要意义。研究表明，将数学概念与实际的日常生活情境联系起来，能提高学生的学习动机和参与度，使他们更深刻地体会到数学与日常生活的相关性（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。通过在熟悉和有意义的经验中进行数学学习，教育工作者能够创造一个学习环境，鼓励学生在真实的环境中探索、探究和应用数学原理，从而促进学生对计算概念更全面和持久的理解。
此外，研究结果的综述强调了将现实生活情境和真实学习体验融入计算概念教学的重要意义。研究表明，将数学概念与实际的日常生活情境联系起来，能提高学生的学习动机和参与度，使他们更深刻地体会到数学与日常生活的相关性（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。通过在熟悉和有意义的经验中进行数学学习，教育工作者能够创造一个学习环境，鼓励学生在真实的环境中探索、探究和应用数学原理，从而促进学生对计算概念更全面和持久的理解。
The reviewed literature consistently underscored the positive impact of the constructivist approach on students' conceptual understanding of numeracy concepts. The integration of hands-on learning experiences, collaborative activities, and the incorporation of real-life contexts played a pivotal role in fostering students' mathematical reasoning abilities and problem-solving skills. The findings highlighted the importance of creating a dynamic and interactive learning environment that promotes active engagement, peer collaboration, and the meaningful application of mathematical concepts, thereby laying a robust foundation for students' continued mathematical development
所查阅的文献一致强调了建构主义方法对学生理解算术概念的积极影响。实践学习体验、协作活动和现实生活情境的整合在培养学生的数学推理能力和解决问题的技能方面发挥了关键作用。研究结果凸显了创建动态互动学习环境的重要性，这种环境能促进学生积极参与、同伴协作和有意义地应用数学概念，从而为学生的持续数学发展奠定坚实的基础。
所查阅的文献一致强调了建构主义方法对学生理解算术概念的积极影响。实践学习体验、协作活动和现实生活情境的整合在培养学生的数学推理能力和解决问题的技能方面发挥了关键作用。研究结果凸显了创建动态互动学习环境的重要性，这种环境能促进学生积极参与、同伴协作和有意义地应用数学概念，从而为学生的持续数学发展奠定坚实的基础。
Theme 2: Alignment with Piaget's Cognitive Development Theory
主题 2：与皮亚杰的认知发展理论保持一致
The meta-analysis findings revealed a robust correspondence between the constructivist approach and Piaget's cognitive development theory, emphasizing the inherent alignment between the two frameworks. The synthesis of the literature elucidated how the constructivist approach facilitated the practical manifestation of Piaget's concepts of assimilation and accommodation within the context of early grade numeracy education (Veraksa, et al., 2023). It was evident that children actively engaged in the construction of mathematical knowledge by assimilating new
荟萃分析结果表明，建构主义方法与皮亚杰的认知发展理论之间有很强的对应性，强调了这两个框架之间的内在一致性。文献综述阐明了建构主义方法如何促进皮亚杰的同化和调适概念在低年级算术教育中的实际体现（Veraksa 等人，2023 年）。很明显，儿童通过吸收新的数学知识，积极参与数学知识的建构。
information into their existing cognitive structures and accommodating these structures to integrate novel numerical concepts, as proposed by Piaget (Winstanley, 2022).
正如皮亚杰提出的那样（Winstanley, 2022），将信息纳入他们现有的认知结构，并适应这些结构以整合新的数字概念。
荟萃分析结果表明，建构主义方法与皮亚杰的认知发展理论之间有很强的对应性，强调了这两个框架之间的内在一致性。文献综述阐明了建构主义方法如何促进皮亚杰的同化和调适概念在低年级算术教育中的实际体现（Veraksa 等人，2023 年）。很明显，儿童通过吸收新的数学知识，积极参与数学知识的建构。
information into their existing cognitive structures and accommodating these structures to integrate novel numerical concepts, as proposed by Piaget (Winstanley, 2022).
正如皮亚杰提出的那样（Winstanley, 2022），将信息纳入他们现有的认知结构，并适应这些结构以整合新的数字概念。
One of the key insights derived from the reviewed literature was the pivotal role of developmentally appropriate instructional practices in fostering the application of Piaget's cognitive development theory within the constructivist approach. Play-based learning activities and manipulative-based tasks were identified as effective pedagogical strategies that provided a conducive environment for children to progress through Piaget's stages of cognitive development (Kilag, et al., 2023). The integration of play-based learning activities, such as educational games and interactive puzzles, facilitated a playful and engaging learning environment that encouraged children to explore mathematical concepts in a manner that aligned with their cognitive abilities and developmental stages (Valentim, et al., 2023). Similarly, the utilization of manipulatives in early grade numeracy education provided children with tangible tools to manipulate and explore numerical relationships, thereby supporting their cognitive development in accordance with Piaget's theory (Kejstová, et al., 2023).
从所查阅的文献中得出的一个重要见解是，适合儿童发展的教学实践在促进皮亚杰认知发展理论在建构主义方法中的应用方面发挥着关键作用。以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务被认为是有效的教学策略，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段中取得进步提供了有利的环境（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。游戏式学习活动的整合，如教育游戏和互动拼图，促进了游戏性和参与性的学习环境，鼓励儿童以符合其认知能力和发展阶段的方式探索数学概念（Valentim 等人，2023 年）。同样，在低年级算术教育中使用操作工具，为儿童提供了操作和探索数字关系的有形工具，从而支持了他们符合皮亚杰理论的认知发展（Kejstová 等人，2023 年）。
从所查阅的文献中得出的一个重要见解是，适合儿童发展的教学实践在促进皮亚杰认知发展理论在建构主义方法中的应用方面发挥着关键作用。以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务被认为是有效的教学策略，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段中取得进步提供了有利的环境（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。游戏式学习活动的整合，如教育游戏和互动拼图，促进了游戏性和参与性的学习环境，鼓励儿童以符合其认知能力和发展阶段的方式探索数学概念（Valentim 等人，2023 年）。同样，在低年级算术教育中使用操作工具，为儿童提供了操作和探索数字关系的有形工具，从而支持了他们符合皮亚杰理论的认知发展（Kejstová 等人，2023 年）。
Furthermore, the synthesis of the findings emphasized the significance of creating a supportive and interactive learning environment that stimulated children's curiosity and intrinsic motivation for learning. The integration of developmentally appropriate instructional practices within the constructivist approach facilitated a learning environment that encouraged children to actively explore, experiment, and make sense of numerical concepts based on their individual experiences and interactions (Kilag, et al., 2023). By providing opportunities for hands-on exploration and collaborative problem-solving, educators were able to create a learning environment that promoted children's cognitive growth and development in alignment with Piaget's cognitive development theory.
此外，研究结果的综述强调了创造一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境能激发儿童的好奇心和内在学习动力。在建构主义方法中融入适合儿童发展的教学实践，有助于营造一种学习环境，鼓励儿童积极探索、实验，并根据个人经验和互动来理解数字概念（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。通过提供动手探索和合作解决问题的机会，教育工作者能够创造出一种符合皮亚杰认知发展理论的学习环境，促进儿童的认知成长和发展。
此外，研究结果的综述强调了创造一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境能激发儿童的好奇心和内在学习动力。在建构主义方法中融入适合儿童发展的教学实践，有助于营造一种学习环境，鼓励儿童积极探索、实验，并根据个人经验和互动来理解数字概念（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。通过提供动手探索和合作解决问题的机会，教育工作者能够创造出一种符合皮亚杰认知发展理论的学习环境，促进儿童的认知成长和发展。
The integration of developmentally appropriate instructional practices, including play-based learning activities and manipulative-based tasks, provided a conducive setting for children to progress through Piaget's stages of cognitive development and develop a robust foundation in early grade numeracy. The findings emphasized the importance of creating an engaging and supportive learning environment that fosters children's cognitive growth and development in alignment with Piaget's theoretical framework.
融合了适合儿童发展的教学实践，包括以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段取得进步和在低年级计算能力方面打下坚实的基础提供了有利的环境。研究结果表明，根据皮亚杰的理论框架，创造一个有吸引力和支持性的学习环境对促进儿童的认知成长和发展非常重要。
融合了适合儿童发展的教学实践，包括以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段取得进步和在低年级计算能力方面打下坚实的基础提供了有利的环境。研究结果表明，根据皮亚杰的理论框架，创造一个有吸引力和支持性的学习环境对促进儿童的认知成长和发展非常重要。
Theme 3: Pedagogical Implications for Educators
主题 3：对教育工作者的教学影响
The synthesis of the literature yielded critical pedagogical implications for educators aiming to incorporate a constructivist framework into early grade numeracy education. The findings emphasized the importance of cultivating a supportive and interactive learning environment that fosters active participation, critical thinking, and collaborative problem-solving among young learners (Botella López, 2023). Educators were encouraged to create an atmosphere that encourages open dialogue, exploration, and inquiry, thereby stimulating students' intrinsic motivation and curiosity for learning (Jasper-Abowei & Victor-Ishikaku, 2023).
文献综述为旨在将建构主义框架纳入低年级算术教育的教育工作者提供了重要的教学启示。研究结果强调了培养支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境能促进青少年学习者的积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题（Botella López, 2023）。研究鼓励教育工作者营造一种鼓励公开对话、探索和研究的氛围，从而激发学生内在的学习动力和好奇心（Jasper-Abowei & Victor-Ishikaku, 2023）。
文献综述为旨在将建构主义框架纳入低年级算术教育的教育工作者提供了重要的教学启示。研究结果强调了培养支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，这种环境能促进青少年学习者的积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题（Botella López, 2023）。研究鼓励教育工作者营造一种鼓励公开对话、探索和研究的氛围，从而激发学生内在的学习动力和好奇心（Jasper-Abowei & Victor-Ishikaku, 2023）。
Furthermore, the reviewed literature underscored the significance of leveraging manipulatives, educational games, and real-life contexts to facilitate hands-on learning experiences that promote a holistic understanding of numeracy concepts among young learners (Kilag, et al., 2023). The integration of manipulatives, such as counting blocks and geometric shapes, provided students with tangible tools to explore mathematical concepts in a concrete and meaningful manner, thereby fostering a deeper conceptual understanding of numerical relationships and operations (Granada, et al., 2023). Additionally, the incorporation of educational games and interactive learning tasks enhanced students' engagement and motivation, creating an enjoyable and immersive learning environment that supported their cognitive development and mathematical growth (Olson, 2022).
此外，所查阅的文献强调了利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验的重要性，从而促进青少年学习者对计算概念的全面理解（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。数块和几何图形等操作工具的融入，为学生提供了有形的工具，使他们能够以具体而有意义的方式探索数学概念，从而加深对数字关系和运算的概念性理解（Granada 等人，2023 年）。此外，教育游戏和互动学习任务的融入提高了学生的参与度和积极性，创造了一个令人愉悦和身临其境的学习环境，有助于他们的认知发展和数学成长（Olson，2022 年）。
此外，所查阅的文献强调了利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验的重要性，从而促进青少年学习者对计算概念的全面理解（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。数块和几何图形等操作工具的融入，为学生提供了有形的工具，使他们能够以具体而有意义的方式探索数学概念，从而加深对数字关系和运算的概念性理解（Granada 等人，2023 年）。此外，教育游戏和互动学习任务的融入提高了学生的参与度和积极性，创造了一个令人愉悦和身临其境的学习环境，有助于他们的认知发展和数学成长（Olson，2022 年）。
Moreover, the synthesis of the findings emphasized the significance of implementing formative assessment practices that align with the principles of the constructivist approach. Educators were encouraged to employ assessment strategies that focused on students' ongoing progress, understanding, and application of numeracy concepts within real-world contexts (Kilag, et al., 2023). Formative assessments, such as observations, student portfolios, and selfassessments, enabled educators to gather valuable insights into students' learning processes and provided opportunities for timely feedback and targeted interventions to support their mathematical development and conceptual understanding (Ssemugenyi, 2023).
此外，研究结果的综述强调了实施符合建构主义方法原则的形成性评估实践的重要性。我们鼓励教育工作者采用评估策略，关注学生在真实世界背景下对算术概念的持续进展、理解和应用（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。形成性评估，如观察、学生作品集和自我评估，使教育工作者能够收集学生学习过程的宝贵见解，并提供及时反馈和有针对性干预的机会，以支持他们的数学发展和概念理解（Ssemugenyi，2023 年）。
此外，研究结果的综述强调了实施符合建构主义方法原则的形成性评估实践的重要性。我们鼓励教育工作者采用评估策略，关注学生在真实世界背景下对算术概念的持续进展、理解和应用（Kilag 等人，2023 年）。形成性评估，如观察、学生作品集和自我评估，使教育工作者能够收集学生学习过程的宝贵见解，并提供及时反馈和有针对性干预的机会，以支持他们的数学发展和概念理解（Ssemugenyi，2023 年）。
The findings emphasized the importance of creating an engaging and supportive learning environment that fosters active participation, critical thinking, and collaborative problem-solving among young learners. Educators were encouraged to leverage manipulatives, educational games, and real-life contexts to facilitate hands-on learning experiences that promote a holistic understanding of numeracy concepts. Additionally, the findings emphasized the significance of incorporating formative assessment practices that align with the principles of the constructivist approach, enabling educators to monitor students' progress and provide timely feedback to support their mathematical development and conceptual understanding.
研究结果强调了创建一个吸引人的、支持性的学习环境的重要性，这种环境可以培养青少年学生的积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题的能力。我们鼓励教育工作者利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验，从而促进对计算概念的全面理解。此外，研究结果还强调了纳入符合建构主义方法原则的形成性评估实践的重要性，使教育工作者能够监测学生的学习进度并及时提供反馈，以支持他们的数学发展和概念理解。
研究结果强调了创建一个吸引人的、支持性的学习环境的重要性，这种环境可以培养青少年学生的积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题的能力。我们鼓励教育工作者利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验，从而促进对计算概念的全面理解。此外，研究结果还强调了纳入符合建构主义方法原则的形成性评估实践的重要性，使教育工作者能够监测学生的学习进度并及时提供反馈，以支持他们的数学发展和概念理解。
Theme 4: Challenges and Considerations
主题 4：挑战和考虑因素
While the constructivist framework demonstrated an overall positive impact on early grade numeracy education, the findings brought attention to several significant challenges and considerations that demand careful consideration. The meta-analysis underscored the crucial need for continuous professional development opportunities for educators, enabling them to deepen their understanding of the theoretical foundations of the constructivist approach and its practical application within the classroom (Van der Westhuizen, 2023). Equipping educators with the necessary knowledge and skills is essential to ensure the effective implementation of the constructivist framework and to support students' cognitive development and mathematical growth (Nkundabakura, et al., 2023).
虽然建构主义框架对低年级算术教育产生了总体上积极的影响，但研究结果也提请人们注意需要认真考虑的一些重大挑战和注意事项。荟萃分析强调，教育工作者亟需持续的专业发展机会，使他们能够加深对建构主义方法的理论基础及其在课堂中的实际应用的理解（Van der Westhuizen，2023 年）。让教育工作者掌握必要的知识和技能，对于确保有效实施建构主义框架、支持学生的认知发展和数学成长至关重要（Nkundabakura 等人，2023 年）。
虽然建构主义框架对低年级算术教育产生了总体上积极的影响，但研究结果也提请人们注意需要认真考虑的一些重大挑战和注意事项。荟萃分析强调，教育工作者亟需持续的专业发展机会，使他们能够加深对建构主义方法的理论基础及其在课堂中的实际应用的理解（Van der Westhuizen，2023 年）。让教育工作者掌握必要的知识和技能，对于确保有效实施建构主义框架、支持学生的认知发展和数学成长至关重要（Nkundabakura 等人，2023 年）。
Furthermore, the findings emphasized the critical importance of adequate resource allocation to facilitate the successful integration of the constructivist approach in early grade numeracy education. The meta-analysis highlighted the necessity of providing educators with access to developmentally appropriate instructional materials, manipulatives, and technological tools that align with the principles of the constructivist framework (Kilag, et al. 2023). Adequate resource allocation enables educators to create a dynamic and engaging learning environment that fosters students' active engagement and conceptual understanding of numeracy concepts.
此外，研究结果还强调，充足的资源分配对于促进建构主义方法成功融入低年级算术教育至关重要。荟萃分析强调，必须为教育工作者提供符合建构主义框架原则的、适合其发展的教学材料、操作材料和技术工具（Kilag 等，2023 年）。充足的资源分配使教育工作者能够创造一个充满活力、引人入胜的学习环境，促进学生积极参与和对计算概念的理解。
此外，研究结果还强调，充足的资源分配对于促进建构主义方法成功融入低年级算术教育至关重要。荟萃分析强调，必须为教育工作者提供符合建构主义框架原则的、适合其发展的教学材料、操作材料和技术工具（Kilag 等，2023 年）。充足的资源分配使教育工作者能够创造一个充满活力、引人入胜的学习环境，促进学生积极参与和对计算概念的理解。
The meta-analysis emphasized the need for policymakers and educational stakeholders to address these challenges to ensure the effective integration of the constructivist approach in early grade numeracy education. Providing comprehensive and ongoing professional development opportunities for educators and allocating sufficient resources for the implementation of the constructivist framework are crucial steps toward fostering a supportive learning environment that nurtures students' cognitive development and mathematical understanding (Asekun, 2023). By addressing these challenges, educational institutions can create an inclusive and conducive learning environment that empowers educators to implement the constructivist approach effectively, thus laying a strong foundation for students' continued academic success and cognitive growth.
荟萃分析强调，政策制定者和教育利益相关者需要应对这些挑战，以确保建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的有效整合。为教育工作者提供全面、持续的专业发展机会，并为实施建构主义框架分配充足的资源，是营造有利的学习环境，培养学生认知发展和数学理解能力的关键步骤（Asekun，2023 年）。通过应对这些挑战，教育机构可以创造一个包容和有利的学习环境，使教育工作者能够有效地实施建构主义方法，从而为学生的持续学业成功和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。
荟萃分析强调，政策制定者和教育利益相关者需要应对这些挑战，以确保建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的有效整合。为教育工作者提供全面、持续的专业发展机会，并为实施建构主义框架分配充足的资源，是营造有利的学习环境，培养学生认知发展和数学理解能力的关键步骤（Asekun，2023 年）。通过应对这些挑战，教育机构可以创造一个包容和有利的学习环境，使教育工作者能够有效地实施建构主义方法，从而为学生的持续学业成功和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。
The findings of the meta-analysis underscored the significant impact of the constructivist framework, guided by Piaget's cognitive development theory, in enhancing early grade numeracy education. The alignment between the theoretical underpinnings of the constructivist approach and the developmental needs of young learners emphasized the importance of fostering a learning environment that promotes active engagement, critical thinking, and collaborative learning experiences to nurture a strong foundation in numeracy among children.
荟萃分析的结果强调了以皮亚杰认知发展理论为指导的建构主义框架对加强低年级计算教育的重要影响。建构主义方法的理论基础与年幼学习者的发展需求相吻合，强调了营造一个促进积极参与、批判性思维和协作学习体验的学习环境，为培养儿童计算能力打下坚实基础的重要性。
荟萃分析的结果强调了以皮亚杰认知发展理论为指导的建构主义框架对加强低年级计算教育的重要影响。建构主义方法的理论基础与年幼学习者的发展需求相吻合，强调了营造一个促进积极参与、批判性思维和协作学习体验的学习环境，为培养儿童计算能力打下坚实基础的重要性。
Conclusion: 结论
This comprehensive meta-analysis has shed light on the significance of incorporating a constructivist framework, guided by Jean Piaget's cognitive development theory, in early grade numeracy education. The analysis of the literature revealed the substantial positive impact of the constructivist approach on students' conceptua understanding of numeracy concepts, emphasizing the effectiveness of hands-on learning experiences, collaborative activities, and the integration of manipulatives in fostering students' mathematical reasoning abilities and problem solving skills.
这项综合荟萃分析阐明了以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为指导，将建构主义框架纳入低年级算术教育的重要意义。文献分析表明，建构主义方法对学生理解算术概念有很大的积极影响，强调了实践学习体验、协作活动和操作工具的整合在培养学生数学推理能力和解决问题能力方面的有效性。
这项综合荟萃分析阐明了以让-皮亚杰（Jean Piaget）的认知发展理论为指导，将建构主义框架纳入低年级算术教育的重要意义。文献分析表明，建构主义方法对学生理解算术概念有很大的积极影响，强调了实践学习体验、协作活动和操作工具的整合在培养学生数学推理能力和解决问题能力方面的有效性。
Moreover, the alignment between the constructivist approach and Piaget's cognitive development theory was underscored, highlighting the role of assimilation and accommodation in children's active construction of mathematical knowledge. The integration of developmentally appropriate instructional practices, such as play-based learning activities and manipulative-based tasks, provided a conducive setting for children to progress through Piaget's stages of cognitive development and develop a robust foundation in early grade numeracy.
此外，建构主义方法与皮亚杰认知发展理论的一致性也得到了强调，突出了同化和调适在儿童积极建构数学知识中的作用。融合了适合儿童发展的教学实践，如以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段中取得进步提供了有利环境，并为低年级的计算能力打下了坚实的基础。
此外，建构主义方法与皮亚杰认知发展理论的一致性也得到了强调，突出了同化和调适在儿童积极建构数学知识中的作用。融合了适合儿童发展的教学实践，如以游戏为基础的学习活动和以操作为基础的任务，为儿童在皮亚杰的认知发展阶段中取得进步提供了有利环境，并为低年级的计算能力打下了坚实的基础。
The synthesis of the literature also emphasized crucial pedagogical implications for educators seeking to implement a constructivist framework, emphasizing the importance of creating a supportive and interactive learning environment that encourages active participation, critical thinking, and collaborative problem-solving. Educators were encouraged to leverage manipulatives, educational games, and real-life contexts to facilitate hands-on learning experiences that fostered a holistic understanding of numeracy concepts among young learners.
文献综述还强调了对寻求实施建构主义框架的教育工作者的重要教学意义，强调了创建一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，以鼓励积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题。我们鼓励教育工作者利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验，从而培养青少年学生对计算概念的全面理解。
文献综述还强调了对寻求实施建构主义框架的教育工作者的重要教学意义，强调了创建一个支持性和互动性学习环境的重要性，以鼓励积极参与、批判性思维和合作解决问题。我们鼓励教育工作者利用操作工具、教育游戏和现实生活情境来促进动手学习体验，从而培养青少年学生对计算概念的全面理解。
However, the findings also brought attention to several challenges and considerations, including the need for ongoing professional development opportunities for educators and the necessity of adequate resource allocation to support the effective integration of the constructivist approach in early grade numeracy education. Addressing these challenges is crucial in creating an inclusive and conducive learning environment that nurtures students' cognitive development and mathematical understanding.
然而，研究结果也让我们注意到一些挑战和需要考虑的问题，包括教育工作者需要持续的专业发展机会，以及必须分配足够的资源以支持建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的有效整合。应对这些挑战对于创造一个包容性的、有利于培养学生认知发展和数学理解能力的学习环境至关重要。
然而，研究结果也让我们注意到一些挑战和需要考虑的问题，包括教育工作者需要持续的专业发展机会，以及必须分配足够的资源以支持建构主义方法在低年级算术教育中的有效整合。应对这些挑战对于创造一个包容性的、有利于培养学生认知发展和数学理解能力的学习环境至关重要。
This meta-analysis underscores the pivotal role of the constructivist framework in early grade numeracy education and provides valuable insights for educators, policymakers, and educational stakeholders. By embracing the principles of the constructivist approach and recognizing its alignment with Piaget's cognitive development theory, educational institutions can foster an engaging and supportive learning environment that promotes students' active engagement, critical thinking, and conceptual understanding of numeracy concepts, thereby laying a strong foundation for their continued academic success and cognitive growth.
这项荟萃分析强调了建构主义框架在低年级算术教育中的关键作用，并为教育工作者、政策制定者和教育利益相关者提供了宝贵的见解。通过接受建构主义方法的原则并认识到其与皮亚杰认知发展理论的一致性，教育机构可以营造一个吸引人的、支持性的学习环境，促进学生积极参与、批判性思考和对算术概念的理解，从而为他们继续取得学业成功和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。
这项荟萃分析强调了建构主义框架在低年级算术教育中的关键作用，并为教育工作者、政策制定者和教育利益相关者提供了宝贵的见解。通过接受建构主义方法的原则并认识到其与皮亚杰认知发展理论的一致性，教育机构可以营造一个吸引人的、支持性的学习环境，促进学生积极参与、批判性思考和对算术概念的理解，从而为他们继续取得学业成功和认知成长奠定坚实的基础。
References: 参考资料
Atta, S. A., Clark, L. J., & Bonyah, E. (2023). Mathematics Learning Experience at the Basic School and Its Influence on One's Program of Choice at the Institution Higher of Learning. Golden Ratio of Social Science and Education, 3(1), 36-49.
Atta, S. A., Clark, L. J., & Bonyah, E. (2023).基础学校的数学学习经历及其对高等教育机构课程选择的影响》。社会科学与教育黄金比例》，3（1），36-49。
Atta, S. A., Clark, L. J., & Bonyah, E. (2023).基础学校的数学学习经历及其对高等教育机构课程选择的影响》。社会科学与教育黄金比例》，3（1），36-49。
Asekun, U. O. (2023). Developing Algebraic Reasoning in the Intermediate Phase to Encourage Critical Thinking: A Case Study of Teachers.
Asekun, U. O. (2023).在中级阶段发展代数推理以鼓励批判性思维：教师案例研究》。
Asekun, U. O. (2023).在中级阶段发展代数推理以鼓励批判性思维：教师案例研究》。
Botella López, M. (2023). Fostering critical thinking since preschool stage in an alternative educational enironment based on children's autonomy. An exploratory case study on a free-learning association in Spain.
Botella López, M. (2023).在基于儿童自主权的另一种教育环境中培养学前阶段的批判性思维。西班牙自由学习协会的探索性案例研究。
Botella López, M. (2023).在基于儿童自主权的另一种教育环境中培养学前阶段的批判性思维。西班牙自由学习协会的探索性案例研究。
Catubig, M. (2023). Exploring Student-Centered Approaches in Mathematics Education: A Qualitative Case Study. Excellencia: International Multi-disciplinary Journal of Education, 1(3), 48-62.
Catubig, M. (2023).探索数学教育中以学生为中心的方法：定性案例研究》。Excellencia：International Multi-disciplinary Journal of Education, 1(3), 48-62.
Catubig, M. (2023).探索数学教育中以学生为中心的方法：定性案例研究》。Excellencia：International Multi-disciplinary Journal of Education, 1(3), 48-62.
Granada, J. R. G., Segura, E. G., & Mesa, F. (2023). A DIDACTIC PROPOSAL FOR TEACHING SELECTED TOPICS OF COMPLEX VARIABLES IN MIDDLE EDUCATION. Journal of Southwest Jiaotong University, 58(4).
Granada, J. R. G., Segura, E. G., & Mesa, F. (2023).中等教育复杂变量选题教学建议》。西南交通大学学报》，58（4）。
Granada, J. R. G., Segura, E. G., & Mesa, F. (2023).中等教育复杂变量选题教学建议》。西南交通大学学报》，58（4）。
Jasper-Abowei, F. E., & Victor-Ishikaku, E. C. (2023). Contextual Learning Approach: A Tool for Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills amongst Learners'. CENTRAL ASIAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL SCIENCES AND HISTORY, 4(5), 72-83.
Jasper-Abowei, F. E., & Victor-Ishikaku, E. C. (2023).情境学习法：A Tool for Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills amongst Learners'.中亚社会科学与历史期刊》，4（5），72-83。
Jasper-Abowei, F. E., & Victor-Ishikaku, E. C. (2023).情境学习法：A Tool for Enhancing Critical Thinking Skills amongst Learners'.中亚社会科学与历史期刊》，4（5），72-83。
Kazak, S., Wegerif, R., & Fujita, T. (2015). The importance of dialogic processes to conceptual development in mathematics. Educational Studies in Mathematics, 90, 105-120.
Kazak, S., Wegerif, R., & Fujita, T. (2015)。对话过程对数学概念发展的重要性。数学教育研究》，90，105-120。
Kazak, S., Wegerif, R., & Fujita, T. (2015)。对话过程对数学概念发展的重要性。数学教育研究》，90，105-120。
Kejstová, M., Stoiber, C., Boucher, M., Kandlhofer, M., Kriglstein, S., & Aigner, W. (2023, October). Construct and Play: Engaging Students with Visualizations through Playful Methods. In Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play (pp. 96-101).
Kejstová, M., Stoiber, C., Boucher, M., Kandlhofer, M., Kriglstein, S., & Aigner, W. (2023, October).建构与游戏：通过游戏方法让学生参与可视化。In Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play (pp. 96-101).
Kejstová, M., Stoiber, C., Boucher, M., Kandlhofer, M., Kriglstein, S., & Aigner, W. (2023, October).建构与游戏：通过游戏方法让学生参与可视化。In Companion Proceedings of the Annual Symposium on Computer-Human Interaction in Play (pp. 96-101).
(2022). ICT Integration in Primary School Classrooms in the time of Pandemic in the Light of Jean Piaget's Cognitive Development Theory. International Journal of Emerging Issues in Early Childhood Education, 4(2), 42-54.
(2022).从让-皮亚杰的认知发展理论看大流行病时期小学课堂的信息和通信技术整合》。国际幼儿教育新问题期刊》，4（2），42-54。
Kilag, O. K. T., Macapobre, K. A., Balicoco, J. R. M., Alfar, J. D., Peras, C. C., & Tapayan, A. A. S. (2023). Emergent literacy: A reading support program for preschoolers' successful phonological awareness in the home context. Science and Education, 4(2), 896-906.
Kilag, O. K. T., Macapobre, K. A., Balicoco, J. R. M., Alfar, J. D., Peras, C. C., & Tapayan, A. A. S. (2023).新兴读写能力：学龄前儿童在家庭环境中成功提高语音意识的阅读支持计划》。科学与教育》，4（2），896-906。
Kilag, O. K. T., Macapobre, K. A., Balicoco, J. R. M., Alfar, J. D., Peras, C. C., & Tapayan, A. A. S. (2023).新兴读写能力：学龄前儿童在家庭环境中成功提高语音意识的阅读支持计划》。科学与教育》，4（2），896-906。
Kilag, O. K. T., & Sasan, J. M. (2023). Unpacking the Role of Instructional Leadership in Teacher Professional Development. Advanced Qualitative Research, 1(1), 63-73.
Kilag, O. K. T., & Sasan, J. M. (2023).Unpacking the Role of Instructional Leadership in Teacher Professional Development.高级定性研究》，1（1），63-73。
Kilag, O. K. T., & Sasan, J. M. (2023).Unpacking the Role of Instructional Leadership in Teacher Professional Development.高级定性研究》，1（1），63-73。
Kilag, O. K. T., Lechadores, V. M. B., Tolin, J. E., Pahayahay, D. Q., Torrefiel, A. P., & Calzada, J. R. D. (2023). Moving beyond the new normal: Understanding Flexible Learning Options (FLOs) on the parameters of Basic Education Learning Continuity Plan (BE-LCP). Science and Education, 4(2), 866-873.
Kilag, O. K. T., Lechadores, V. M. B., Tolin, J. E., Pahayahay, D. Q., Torrefiel, A. P., & Calzada, J. R. D. (2023).超越新常态：了解基础教育学习连续性计划（BE-LCP）参数上的灵活学习选择（FLOs）。科学与教育》，4（2），866-873。
Kilag, O. K. T., Lechadores, V. M. B., Tolin, J. E., Pahayahay, D. Q., Torrefiel, A. P., & Calzada, J. R. D. (2023).超越新常态：了解基础教育学习连续性计划（BE-LCP）参数上的灵活学习选择（FLOs）。科学与教育》，4（2），866-873。
Kilag, O. K. T., Diano Jr, F. M., Malbas, M. H., Mansueto, D. P., Villar, S. P., & Arcillo, M. T. (2023). The role of servant leadership in creating a positive school climate. Science and Education, 4(5), 933-942.
Kilag, O. K. T., Diano Jr, F. M., Malbas, M. H., Mansueto, D. P., Villar, S. P., & Arcillo, M. T. (2023).The role of servant leadership in creating a positive school climate.科学与教育》，4（5），933-942。
Kilag, O. K. T., Diano Jr, F. M., Malbas, M. H., Mansueto, D. P., Villar, S. P., & Arcillo, M. T. (2023).The role of servant leadership in creating a positive school climate.科学与教育》，4（5），933-942。
Kilag, O. K. T., Uy, F. T., Abendan, C. F. K., & Malbas, M. H. (2023). Teaching leadership: an examination of best practices for leadership educators. Science and Education, 4(7), 430-445.
Kilag, O. K. T., Uy, F. T., Abendan, C. F. K., & Malbas, M. H. (2023).领导力教学：领导力教育者最佳实践研究》。科学与教育》，4（7），430-445。
Kilag, O. K. T., Uy, F. T., Abendan, C. F. K., & Malbas, M. H. (2023).领导力教学：领导力教育者最佳实践研究》。科学与教育》，4（7），430-445。
Kilag, O. K. T., Jimenez, J. R., Diano Jr, F. M., Balicoco, J. R. M., Echavez Jr, A. M., & Labasano, A. S. C. (2023). Developing K-2 Filipino children English language oral proficiency through concrete poetry teaching. Science and Education, 4(2), 886-895.
Kilag, O. K. T., Jimenez, J. R., Diano Jr, F. M., Balicoco, J. R. M., Echavez Jr, A. M., & Labasano, A. S. C. (2023).通过具体诗歌教学培养 K-2 级菲律宾儿童的英语口语能力。Science and Education, 4(2), 886-895.
Kilag, O. K. T., Jimenez, J. R., Diano Jr, F. M., Balicoco, J. R. M., Echavez Jr, A. M., & Labasano, A. S. C. (2023).通过具体诗歌教学培养 K-2 级菲律宾儿童的英语口语能力。Science and Education, 4(2), 886-895.
Kilag, O. K. T., Malbas, M. H., Miñoza, J. R., Ledesma, M. M. R., Vestal, A. B. E., & Sasan, J. M. V. (2023). The Views of the Faculty on the Effectiveness of Teacher Education Programs in Developing Lifelong Learning Competence. European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(2), 92-102.
Kilag, O. K. T., Malbas, M. H., Miñoza, J. R., Ledesma, M. M. R., Vestal, A. B. E., & Sasan, J. M. V. (2023).教师对师范教育课程在培养终身学习能力方面的有效性的看法》。European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(2), 92-102.
Kilag, O. K. T., Malbas, M. H., Miñoza, J. R., Ledesma, M. M. R., Vestal, A. B. E., & Sasan, J. M. V. (2023).教师对师范教育课程在培养终身学习能力方面的有效性的看法》。European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(2), 92-102.
Kilag, O. K. T., Abalo, S. J. R., Retes, G. P., & Dalogdog, L. G. (2023). Enhancing Student Learning through the Integration of Connectivism Theory in Blended Learning Environments. EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF INNOVATION IN NONFORMAL EDUCATION, 3(6), 1-10.
Kilag, O. K. T., Abalo, S. J. R., Retes, G. P., & Dalogdog, L. G. (2023).通过在混合学习环境中整合联结主义理论加强学生学习》。欧洲非正规教育创新期刊》，3（6），1-10。
Kilag, O. K. T., Abalo, S. J. R., Retes, G. P., & Dalogdog, L. G. (2023).通过在混合学习环境中整合联结主义理论加强学生学习》。欧洲非正规教育创新期刊》，3（6），1-10。
Kilag, O. K., Tokong, C., Enriquez, B., Deiparine, J., Purisima, R., & Zamora, M. (2023). School Leaders: The Extent of Management Empowerment and Its Impact on Teacher and School Effectiveness. Excellencia: International Multidisciplinary Journal of Education, 1(1), 127-140.
Kilag, O. K., Tokong, C., Enriquez, B., Deiparine, J., Purisima, R., & Zamora, M. (2023).学校领导：学校领导：管理授权的程度及其对教师和学校效能的影响》。Excellencia：Excellencia: International Multidisciplinary Journal of Education, 1(1), 127-140.
Kilag, O. K., Tokong, C., Enriquez, B., Deiparine, J., Purisima, R., & Zamora, M. (2023).学校领导：学校领导：管理授权的程度及其对教师和学校效能的影响》。Excellencia：Excellencia: International Multidisciplinary Journal of Education, 1(1), 127-140.
Kilag, O. K. T., Heyrosa-Malbas, M., Sebial, M. U., & Mayol, J. M. (2023). A Comparative Analysis of Experimental Learning Approach and Traditional Teacher Professional Development Programs. European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(1), 11-16.
Kilag, O. K. T., Heyrosa-Malbas, M., Sebial, M. U., & Mayol, J. M. (2023).实验学习法与传统教师专业发展课程的比较分析》。European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(1), 11-16.
Kilag, O. K. T., Heyrosa-Malbas, M., Sebial, M. U., & Mayol, J. M. (2023).实验学习法与传统教师专业发展课程的比较分析》。European Journal of Higher Education and Academic Advancement, 1(1), 11-16.
Kilag, O. K. T., Aniel, M. T. B., Engbino, V. A., Bubuli, A. L. B., Macapobre, M. D., & Fajardo, J. M. L. (2023). Collaborative-Constructivism Approach Reading Remediation. International Journal of Social Service and Research, 3(2), 376-384.
Kilag, O. K. T., Aniel, M. T. B., Engbino, V. A., Bubuli, A. L. B., Macapobre, M. D., & Fajardo, J. M. L. (2023).Collaborative-Constructivism Approach Reading Remediation.International Journal of Social Service and Research, 3(2), 376-384.
Kilag, O. K. T., Aniel, M. T. B., Engbino, V. A., Bubuli, A. L. B., Macapobre, M. D., & Fajardo, J. M. L. (2023).Collaborative-Constructivism Approach Reading Remediation.International Journal of Social Service and Research, 3(2), 376-384.
Knight, M. (2023). An Attitudinal Study of 5th-Grade Teachers' Perceptions about Mathematics and the Influence on Instruction (Doctoral dissertation, Southern Wesleyan University).
Knight, M. (2023).五年级教师的数学观念及对教学影响的态度研究》（博士论文，南卫斯理大学）。
Knight, M. (2023).五年级教师的数学观念及对教学影响的态度研究》（博士论文，南卫斯理大学）。
Main, P. (2011). Jean Piagets theory of Cognitive Development.
Main, P. (2011).让-皮亚杰认知发展理论》。
Main, P. (2011).让-皮亚杰认知发展理论》。
Muhammad, S. M., Sani, M. A., Abdullahi, F., & Bayaro, A. (2023). The Effect of Using Manipulatives on the Performance Of Pupils in Primary School Mathematics. Journal of Mathematical Sciences & Computational Mathematics, 4(2), 223-232.
Muhammad, S. M., Sani, M. A., Abdullahi, F., & Bayaro, A. (2023).使用计算器对小学生数学成绩的影响》。数学科学与计算数学期刊》，4（2），223-232。
Muhammad, S. M., Sani, M. A., Abdullahi, F., & Bayaro, A. (2023).使用计算器对小学生数学成绩的影响》。数学科学与计算数学期刊》，4（2），223-232。
Nkundabakura, P., Nsengimana, T., Uwamariya, E., Nyirahabimana, P., Nkurunziza, J. B., Mukamwambali, C., ... & Ndihokubwayo, K. (2023). Contribution of Continuous Professional Development (CPD) Training Programme on Rwandan Secondary School Mathematics and Science Teachers' Pedagogical, Technological, and Content knowledge. Education and Information Technologies, 1-31.
Nkundabakura, P., Nsengimana, T., Uwamariya, E., Nyirahabimana, P., Nkurunziza, J. B., Mukamwambali, C., ... & Ndihokubwayo, K. (2023).教育与信息技术》，1-31。Education and Information Technologies, 1-31.
Nkundabakura, P., Nsengimana, T., Uwamariya, E., Nyirahabimana, P., Nkurunziza, J. B., Mukamwambali, C., ... & Ndihokubwayo, K. (2023).教育与信息技术》，1-31。Education and Information Technologies, 1-31.
Olson, B. J. (2022). YOUTH PERCEPTIONS ON LEARNING IN IMMERSIVE VIRTUAL REALITY: DEVELOPING AND ASSESSING ESSENTIAL SOCIOEMOTIONAL SKILLS (Doctoral dissertation, University of Saskatchewan).
Olson, B. J. (2022).YOUTH PERCEPTIONS ON LEARNING IN IMMERSIVE VIRTUAL REALITY: DEVELOPING AND ASSESSING ESSENTIAL SOCIOEMOTIONAL SKILLS (Doctoral dissertation, University of Saskatchewan).
Olson, B. J. (2022).YOUTH PERCEPTIONS ON LEARNING IN IMMERSIVE VIRTUAL REALITY: DEVELOPING AND ASSESSING ESSENTIAL SOCIOEMOTIONAL SKILLS (Doctoral dissertation, University of Saskatchewan).
Saha, S. (2023). Teaching Mathematics through play pedagogy in Government pre-primary classes: An exploratory study (Doctoral dissertation, Brac University).
Saha, S. (2023).通过游戏教学法在政府学前班教授数学：一项探索性研究（博士论文，布拉克大学）。
Saha, S. (2023).通过游戏教学法在政府学前班教授数学：一项探索性研究（博士论文，布拉克大学）。
Sekano, K. G. (2023). The implementation of technology-supported cooperative learning to enhance grade 8 Mathematics learners' self-directed learning (Doctoral dissertation, North-West University (South Africa).).
Sekano, K. G. (2023).实施技术支持的合作学习以提高八年级数学学习者的自主学习能力（南非西北大学博士论文）。
Sekano, K. G. (2023).实施技术支持的合作学习以提高八年级数学学习者的自主学习能力（南非西北大学博士论文）。
Ssemugenyi, F. (2023). Teaching and learning methods compared: A pedagogical evaluation of problem-based learning (PBL) and lecture methods in developing learners' cognitive abilities. Cogent Education, 10(1), 2187943.
Ssemugenyi, F. (2023).教学方法比较：基于问题的学习（PBL）和讲授法在培养学习者认知能力方面的教学评价。Cogent Education, 10(1), 2187943.
Ssemugenyi, F. (2023).教学方法比较：基于问题的学习（PBL）和讲授法在培养学习者认知能力方面的教学评价。Cogent Education, 10(1), 2187943.
Uy, F. T., Sasan, J. M., & Kilag, O. K. (2023). School Principal Administrative-Supervisory Leadership During the Pandemic: A Phenomenological Qualitative Study. International Journal of Theory and Application in Elementary and Secondary School Education, 5(1), 44-62.
Uy, F. T., Sasan, J. M., & Kilag, O. K. (2023).大流行病期间学校校长的行政监督领导力：现象学定性研究》。国际中小学教育理论与应用期刊》，5（1），44-62。
Uy, F. T., Sasan, J. M., & Kilag, O. K. (2023).大流行病期间学校校长的行政监督领导力：现象学定性研究》。国际中小学教育理论与应用期刊》，5（1），44-62。
Valentim, B. D. F. B., Vestena, C. L. B., Costa-Lobo, C., & Schipper, C. M. D. (2023). Intelligence and morality in gifted/high ability: piagetian perspectives. Acta Scientiarum. Education, 45.
Valentim, B. D. F. B., Vestena, C. L. B., Costa-Lobo, C., & Schipper, C. M. D. (2023).资优/高能力者的智力与道德：皮亚杰观点。Acta Scientiarum.Education, 45.
Valentim, B. D. F. B., Vestena, C. L. B., Costa-Lobo, C., & Schipper, C. M. D. (2023).资优/高能力者的智力与道德：皮亚杰观点。Acta Scientiarum.Education, 45.
Van der Westhuizen, B. (2023). Teacher collaboration to enhance play-based learning for the holistic development of young children (Doctoral dissertation, North-West University (South Africa).
Van der Westhuizen, B. (2023).教师合作加强以游戏为基础的学习，促进幼儿的全面发展（博士论文，西北大学（南非）。
Van der Westhuizen, B. (2023).教师合作加强以游戏为基础的学习，促进幼儿的全面发展（博士论文，西北大学（南非）。
Veraksa, N., Colliver, Y., & Sukhikh, V. (2022). Piaget and Vygotsky's play theories: The profile of twenty-firstcentury evidence. In Piaget and Vygotsky in XXI century: Discourse in early childhood education (pp. 165-190). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Veraksa, N., Colliver, Y., & Sukhikh, V. (2022)。皮亚杰和维果斯基的游戏理论：二十一世纪的证据概况。皮亚杰和维果茨基在二十一世纪：幼儿教育论述》（第 165-190 页）。Cham：Springer International Publishing.
Veraksa, N., Colliver, Y., & Sukhikh, V. (2022)。皮亚杰和维果斯基的游戏理论：二十一世纪的证据概况。皮亚杰和维果茨基在二十一世纪：幼儿教育论述》（第 165-190 页）。Cham：Springer International Publishing.
Winstanley, M. A. (2022). Modelling the psychological structure of reasoning. European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 12(2), 31 .
Winstanley, M. A. (2022).Modelling the psychological structure of reasoning.European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 12(2), 31 .
Winstanley, M. A. (2022).Modelling the psychological structure of reasoning.European Journal for Philosophy of Science, 12(2), 31 .